Do you think that can be influenced by certain driving habits people have when driving during the break in period?
Heard both ends of the argument and still not sure what's entirely best for our engines.
Absolutely. From what I've read from most of the performance engine builders is you need to break them in hard to get the best sealing out of the rings. BUT you have to be very specific about how you do it, how often you change the oil, etc. Way more than the average person will do. I think the manufacturers just play it safe with the "easy break-in" as very few people will actually do a "hard break-in" properly.
I can speak from my own experience on a 4-stroke dirt bike engine I recently rebuilt, is that the "flog it" break-in works great. Engine now has great compression and doesn't use any oil. But I followed my builders instructions to the tee, varying RPM, making sure to not overheat, changing the oil at certain intervals, etc.
I've always wondered how much if any break-in is done at the factory. I don't think the engines are test-fired before being fitted into the truck, but I could be wrong.